Validation of the DRAGON/DONJON Code Package for MNR Using the IAEA 10 MW Benchmark Problem

Abstract

The first step in developing a framework for reactor physics analysis is to establish the appropriate and proven reactor physics codes. The chosen code package is tested, by executing a benchmark problem and comparing the results to the accepted standards. The IAEA 10 MW Benchmark problem is suitable for static reactor physics calculations on plate-fueled research reactor systems and has been used previously to validate codes for the McMaster Nuclear Reactor (MNR). The flexible and advanced geometry capabilities of the DRAGON transport theory code make it a desirable tool, and the accompanying DONJON diffusion theory code also has useful features applicable to safety analysis work at MNR. This paper describes the methodology used to benchmark the DRAGON/DONJON code package against this problem and the results herein extend the domain of validation of this code package. The results are directly applicable to MNR and are relevant to a reduced-enrichment fuel program. The DRAGON transport code models, used in this study, are based on the 1-D infinite slab approximation whereas the DONJON diffusion code models are defined in 3-D Cartesian geometry. The cores under consideration are composed of HEU (93% enrichment), MEU (45% enrichment) and LEU (20% enrichment) fuel and are examined in a fresh state, as well as at beginning-of-life (BOL) and end-of-life (EOL) exposures. The required flux plots and flux-ratio plots are included, as are transport theory code k and diffusion theory code keff results. In addition to this, selected isotope atom densities are charted as a function of fuel burnup. Results from this analysis are compared to and are in good agreement with previously published results.